You would have thought that people seeking to promote the Christian faith would avoid claims that are easily falsifiable, but, for some reason, this isn’t always the case.
One claim that is rolled out fairly often is that Christianity isn’t a religion, it’s a relationship with Jesus.
The problem with this claim is that the same people who make this claim, tend to go to church, sing hymns, say prayers, listen to sermons and such like – all things that more or less fit the dictionary definition of religion. Not only that, but many churches claim tax relief on the grounds of the advancement of religion. Just to add to the pattern, the Apostle James encourages Christians to practice pure and genuine religion by caring for orphans and widows.
This certainly looks pretty much like a religion to me!
So what do we make of the “relationship with Jesus” bit? Well, I’m pretty sure that (unlike the word “religion”) this phrase doesn’t actually occur in the Bible. However, the concept does, sort of. The Bible uses various phrases such as reconciled, restored, forgiven and adopted to describe the relationship between the creator and the Christian believer. These are amazing realities and they were achieved at a massive cost to God; the death and resurrection of Jesus. You simply cannot overstate the amazing facts that lie at the core of the Christian faith. God reconciling all things to himself by means of Christ’s death on the cross.
This reality transcends religion, but crucially, the essence of being a Christian is worked out in a corporate religious framework and always has been since the earliest days of the church. There is more to Christianity than a religion but it is still a religion. Claiming that Christianity is not a religion effectively does two things:
- It promotes hyper-individualism, making the Christian faith all about “me and my personal saviour”, which is a denial of Scripture and 2,000 years of church history.
- It makes us look silly because outsiders can clearly see that it is a religion, even if we can’t!
Personally, I would advise avoiding these. There are plenty of amazing things we can say about Christianity without making somewhat dodgy claims.
Claiming that Christianity isn't a religion makes us look silly because outsiders can see that it is, even if we can't. Click To Tweet
3 replies on “Christianity IS a Religion”
I see what you are getting at, and you are right. But I often find myself wondering if Jesus set out to found a religion – with all it’s attendant rigmarole (bureacracy, buildings, fancy dress, bling, clutter…)? Are the religious characteristics of Christian faith so unfortunate that we would like to deny them and say such unhelpful things.
Keep writing Ed!
I agree that Christianity does not need the ‘attendant rigmarole’. The largest Christian congregations are the non denominational ones. If a crowd of Christians meeting together is a religion what is a crowd of fans of any sport or of a political party?
Good thoughts Eddie! My tuppence worth: we have two choices, either Christianity isn’t a religion, because it’s unlike any other ‘religion’. This is an approach taken by many, scholars and laymen alike. OR Christianity IS a religion, and nothing else is, because it’s unlike any other ‘religion’.
The term religion originates in Christian practice – the ‘religious’ were those occupying the monasteries, whereas the ‘secular’ were the Priests in the parish. In this sense, I’d definitely say ‘Christianity IS religion’, and nothing else is. (Calling other ways of life, like Hinduism, a ‘religion’, is to illegitimately pain such with a Christian brush.)
‘Religion’ arose around 1700, synonymously of course with secularism, as in popular definition, religion is what secularism is not. In this sense again, Christianity is the only religion, as no other so-called religion compliments secularism as Christianity does (or at least can do).