Categories
Do Not Use

Throwback: Reasons for Bible Translation – Missionaries

There is no Methodist or Baptist Bible. Translators work hard to make sure that the text is translated faithfully without a bias towards any particular confession. For the most part, translation teams are interdenominational and no one group is allowed to dominate, even if they wanted to.

This post is a couple of years old and it is part of a series on why Bible translation needs to happen.

For the next few blog posts, I’ll be going back to my roots and talking about Bible Translation. I’d like to examine some of the reasons that are given for promoting the translation of the Bible into minority languages around the world. If I have the energy, I might look at some of the objections, too.

The first thing I’d like to talk about is the role of missionaries.

For the last two hundred years, or so, missionaries from the Western world have had played a major role in the unprecedented spread of Christianity around the world. For the most part, modern missionaries have travelled from richer, more technologically advanced and militarily powerful nations to poorer and less advanced nations. For a significant period, mission took place against the background of Empire and conquest. This is not to say that all missionaries were colonialists, far from it – but there was generally an economic and power disparity between the missionary and the people to whom they went. This inevitably had an impact on the way in which the gospel was transmitted, received and perceived. It is, perhaps, significant, that the current exponential levels of growth that we are seeing in the African church didn’t happen till after the colonial era had finished.

Even if we ignore the impact of colonialism and the power disparity between the west and the rest, missionaries transmit the Christian message with a bit of spin. Baptist missionaries plant Baptist churches, Methodist missionaries, Methodist churches and so on. Missionaries bring their background to the situation that they are working in; it is inevitable.

To some extent, Bible translation provides an antidote to this.

The Bible comes without denominational spin. There is no Methodist or Baptist Bible. Translators work hard to make sure that the text is translated faithfully without a bias towards any particular confession. For the most part, translation teams are interdenominational and no one group is allowed to dominate, even if they wanted to. That being said, research has shown that while the translated Bible does not favour one denomination over another, the way in which people read and study it is to some extent a product of their confessional background.

The Bible Judges Missionaries.  There is nothing more humiliating (or healthy?) for a Bible translation team leader to see their own faults being laid bare and discussed by proxy as the team get to grips with a Bible passage that addresses a particular sin. I know, I’ve been that team leader. Any illusions that a missionary-translator hold about their own superiority get shattered at the translation desk.

The Bible Addresses Issues That Missionaries Don’t. People in different situations see things in the Bible that others miss. Missionaries come with a whole load of cultural baggage and they will never be able to see the Bible in the way that people from a very different culture will. By making the Bible available to people, translators provide the capacity for people to dive into the Bible on their own and to dig out things that the missionaries would never see in a million years.

The Bible Sticks Around. Missionaries go home, but the Bible is a lasting legacy for a church which can endure for years.

To some extent, the issues that I’m talking about in this post are captured by a quote from Cameron Townsend, the founder of Wycliffe Bible Translators:

“The greatest missionary is the Bible in the mother tongue. It needs no furlough and is never considered a foreigner.” 

As I point out here, this quote has a number of significant problems, but it does capture a germ of truth.

Posts in This Series

3 replies on “Throwback: Reasons for Bible Translation – Missionaries”

Whilst generally true, sadly there are a lot of English language bibles “out there” which do have a particular spin. Sometimes these have even been translated by a cross denominational team – but selection into that team has seemingly required signing up to a particular view on certain issues of interpretation.

(I’ve chosen to post this here rather than on Facebook, judging that on Facebook it would get more non-Christian viewers, and I’m concerned to put them off reading the bible at all)

Thanks for responding, Eddie. I’ll take a moment to say I find you posts very often encouraging, challenging, and helpful. I share a number of them with my pastor & elders in church (I was one of them until recently).

One area I had in mind was the policy decision that translations make on when to translate a word with its “ecclesiastical meaning” and when to translate it with its “secular meaning”. The two examples I have in mind are πρεσβύτης/πρεσβῦτις and ἀποστόλους.

Many translations appear to have decided that πρεσβύτης sometimes means elder (a role) and sometimes old man, but πρεσβῦτις can only mean old woman.

ἀποστόλους sometimes refers to a person with a particular role/gifting in the church, and sometimes it has its secular meaning of ambassador. A translation team has to decide when to use each word.

I guess another is the decision / policy teams have on whether to translate to “brethren” or somehow make sure the term includes women. Part of that is of course keeping an eye on the changing use of the English language.

As you have often shown, there are very few words / phrases where the decision how to translate them is simple.

Comments are closed.