In this post, I will attempt to make some predictions about the state of British based mission agencies in the year 2050. This is a follow up to my posts on the UK Church and the World Church in the year 2050.
This graph of trends over the few decades of the twentieth century is a useful starting place.
The blue line shows the average attendance at Church of England churches for the period 1970-2001 (figures from here), which we can assume to be more or less representative of church attendance as a whole, in the absence of other data. The red line is the number of mission agencies in the UK during the same time period (this only covers agencies which are members of Global Connections and so is an underestimate, if anything).
One might wish to argue with the exact figures, but the trends are clear; as church attendance declines, the number of mission agencies in the UK increases. There are more and more agencies seeking support from a shrinking constituency. This is not sustainable even in the short to mid-term, much less by 2050.
In addition, the trends that were addressed in the earlier two posts in this blog series, namely the shift in the centre of gravity from historic Christendom to the rest of the world, raise questions about role of agencies themselves. It is no wonder that David Smith has written:
“What is clear by now is that both the concept of mission as a one-way movement from Christendom to the un-evangelised world, and the structures devised at the close of the eighteenth century to facilitate that movement, have been overtaken by a historical developments that render them increasingly irrelevant and redundant.†(Mission After Christendom p.116)
It isn’t rocket science to suggest that the number of mission agencies based in the UK will decline precipitously over the next 35 years. I suggest that there are three types of agency which will survive.
- International agencies who have a significant proportion of their leadership and structure based outside of the UK. Agencies like this will continue to exist, but they may have a very reduced presence in the UK.
- Small agencies who basically exist to support the ministry of one person or a couple. These sorts of agencies, rooted in a church or a group of friends, will continue to spring up in the future.
- Large relief and development agencies; however, I suspect that the pressures on them will be such that they will lose their Evangelical distinctives and will increasingly resemble Oxfam, Save the Children or other aid agencies.
In a comment on an earlier post, I was asked what we could do to avoid the decline in the church that I predicted. I don’t have an answer, so I didn’t give one. However, I do think that there are steps that the leadership of agencies need to take to adapt to the future.
- We need to address the issue of fragmentation. There are far too many agencies all doing similar things and all competing for resources from the same group of people. We need visionary leaders (at board level) who will reduce the number of agencies either through merger or closure.
- Agencies need to look to supporting and encouraging Christians in other parts of the world, rather than just sending missionaries from the UK. This will entail a major programme to re-educate the British mission supporting public on the new realities of the Christian world.
- Above everything else, mission leadership and boards need to take serious stock of their situation and the future trends. We cannot assume that the status quo will continue, much less can we live in the glory days of the past. Even those agencies which are doing well at the current time will face resourcing problems in the next 10-15 years.
I may sound pessimistic, but I believe that we cannot avoid a crisis among British mission agencies, however, with good leadership and planning we can avoid a hard landing.


34 replies on “Mission Agencies 2050”
Would be interesting to see the trend in average size of the agency. My guess is that this is declining with the increase in number of agencies, i.e. agencies are more and more serving niches or (as you mention) particular individuals. In which case the actual missionary population may end up being fairly stable.
Mission Agencies 2050: http://t.co/SdesbIWI1k via @kouya
That data isn’t easy to get hold of, though I am planning to try over the next few months. I am looking at financial turnover, which is publicly available, though.
I note the shameless use of a cat photo to get people to click on this and read it.
If you are in mission or church leadership, you need to deal with these issues before it is too late:
http://t.co/NbMjWHlpn1
Simon Cozens liked this on Facebook.
Lois Baker liked this on Facebook.
Perhaps ‘tentmaking’ is the way forward?
I’ll be looking at the question of mission ‘per se’ (rather than agencies) in a later post Nev. Tentmaking is an option, but the big question is who will make the tents and where will they make them?
I blogged on that yesterday, Sarah, though the situation is not as straightforward as you suggest it is. In all probability, many missionaries will still get NHS treatment and the others will need to tweak their overseas health insurance to include three months cover in the UK. https://www.kouya.net/?p=6965
Tony Watkins liked this on Facebook.
Jon Barnes liked this on Facebook.
George Semerenko liked this on Facebook.
Nev McCormack liked this on Facebook.
We support a missionary in another country and at the moment the pound is strong enough to make our money go a long way and support a very godly lady. Global opportunities to do this kind of thing have opened up more. So I have mixed feelings as I read this article. Sadness but also great hope. Partnerships with christians from other countries open up so many possibilities.
A million Christians ought to be able to sustain 100 mission organisations, if enough of them heeded the call (a big ‘if’, I know!)
But why would you want 100 administrations, back office functions and so on? Especially when there is so much overlap.
I remember repping at Spring Harvest quite a long time ago and 90 missions were represented. Someone put up a notice saying ‘don’t fancy any of the organisations represented here – why not start your own!’ Still makes me cringe even now.
Good point! A dozen at most would suffice, ideally strategically located around the UK.
Though the worst scenario is missionaries who go out with NO mission agency at all. Seen a few of those over the years :-/
Gregg Ramirez liked this on Facebook.
Tim Tillinghast liked this on Facebook.
Dave Monument liked this on Facebook.
Insightful thoughts. I wonder if the growth in agencies is a reflection of:
1. The fragmenting of UK evangelicalism over the period and growth in number of church groups.
2. The decline in trust of ‘organisations’ means we prefer smaller organisations to larger ones.
3. As churches and Christians we want things to be done our way and so find people like us, rather than putting our preferences to one side to work for some greater good.
Insightful thoughts. I wonder if the growth in agencies is a reflection of:
1. The fragmenting of U… http://t.co/bVFVknv82m
RT @NeilBrighton: Insightful thoughts. I wonder if the growth in agencies is a reflection of:
1. The fragmenting of U… http://t.co/bVFVkn…
I can remember this conversation going on in Global Connections back in the early noughties, then again at the start of this decade as we faced the financial crash – and yet so few agencies have closed or merged during this period. I suspect what you say will happen, but as very few agencies have actually addressed the issue proactively in two decades (depsite repeated warnings and discussion), it will come at a crisis point rather than a managed process
Interesting blog by @kouya on the future on mission agencies. Pay attention and listen. Please! http://t.co/GKS96j4M4c
The Bebbington thesis that evangelical structures follow cultural change seems highly relevant here. In Western countries, self-expression is more important than material survival (Inglehart thesis). Mission partners all want to express their distinctive vision and Western wealth makes it possible. Britain can afford to have 1000 channels on Sky, each watched by a tiny audience, and the evangelical church can afford to have 100 mission agencies, each with its glossy magazine. Those of us who have lived in survival cultures deplore the waste of resources, but if you live in Waitrose world it doesn’t feel like such a pressing issue. I fear you have an uphill task. If you want to do more work on this, it would be interesting to study Actions Partners’ incorporation into Pioneers, since that seems to be the future you want.
I’ve not really addressed the issue of why there are so many agencies in this post, though I may well look at that at some point. I’m sure you are right that Bebbington’s thesis is part of the reasoning.
I’m not sure that the Pioneers/Action Partners merger is the future that I want. To be honest, I’m not sure what the best options for the future are and I’m sure that it will be a complex mix. However, my concern is that agencies start to think about this and get to grips with their declining support base and changes in world Christianity before they face a crisis.
RT @JDSayersMish: Interesting blog by @kouya on the future on mission agencies. Pay attention and listen. Please! http://t.co/GKS96j4M4c
Article predicting the state of British based mission agencies in the year 2050 @kouya http://t.co/bmBoWIYJbp
I suspect that every mission director is already grappling with the realities you point out, Eddie. Thanks for the encouragement to share/pool resources as best we can, something certainly in the forefront of our thinking in conversation with other like-minded mission agencies for future partnerships.
However, to my mind, we need UK answers for mission organisations that better serve local churches and networks with an internationally-connected vision. It’s good to point out that the old ‘west-to-the-rest’ model is redundant. This is old news, though, we need to engage with the ‘new’ realities facing Christ’s mission from multi-cultural Britain. Serving in Mission is already working on a multi-directional approach with others.
Hi Steve, thanks for your comment – good to see you here. I agree with some of what you say, but not all of it. I must admit that I am far from convinced that every mission director is grappling with these issues; some are, but many others are just too busy with day to day stuff and others don’t even have issues like this on the radar. In addition, very few boards, which is where the energy for the sort of major change that we need has to come from, are looking at this sort of thing.
Where I do agree is that multi-cultural, multi-dimensional agencies have to be a significant part of the future. Whether the historic mission agencies can make the transition to a radical new future is something that only the future will reveal.
A couple of years ago, I blogged on a related theme; this post adds something to the debate and also has a link to an excellent post (not by me) which looks at some of the challenges faced by agencies.