Last week, I was sitting in a discussion session on Christian responses to violence. It wasn’t an easy afternoon; we discussed persecution of Christians in the Middle-East, violence against women and other tough subjects.
At the same time, this quote came across my twitter timeline:
Burnout is the result of doing the work of God apart from the presence of God.
Like many short, pithy sayings, there is a grain of truth in this, but only a grain.
Burnout is a mental and emotional response to severe or sustained stress and trauma; faced with overwhelming circumstances, people stop functioning normally and exhibit a variety of different symptoms.
Sitting in a seminar on responses to violence, I was reminded – once again – that Christian workers often find themselves in very difficult and stressful situations. War, robbery, disease, rape; it is not unusual for missionaries to find themselves confronted by stresses such as these; and it is not unknown for people going through these stresses to suffer burnout. I’ve been close, myself.
To say that people who suffer burnout in these situations have been ‘doing the work of God apart from the presence of God’ is the worst sort of sanctimonious tripe. No one says that getting malaria is due to not being in God’s presence, so why do we assume that Christians won’t face the normal human responses to stress and trauma?
Trite little phrases like this one don’t help; instead they heap guilt on the heads of people who are already suffering as a result of following God into tough places. A far better response comes from Marjory Foyle, who’s book on stress among missionaries is called Honourably Wounded. We should honour and respect those who have been hurt on the front line, not make them feel bad.
In the end, suggesting that ‘working in the presence of God’ will prevent you facing the problems of stress and trauma is nothing more than the prosperity Gospel in another guise. I wrote this in an earlier post, which is worth revisiting on this subject:
I know people who have been (unfairly) dragged through the courts in a foreign country, mugged in the street, robbed with violence in their own homes and the list goes on. Some friends have lost children to tropical diseases and others have lost their own lives to disease, violence or accident. In all of these cases it was because people had put themselves in harm’s way because they were following Jesus.
If you are interested in a serious look at the causes and responses to missionary stress, this paper is a good place to start.
A prize of a round of applause will be given to the first person to identify where the title for this post comes from.

33 replies on “It’s Better To Burn Out, Than It Is To Rust”
Tnx Eddie, great post…
Paul Bailie liked this on Facebook.
Adriaan Adams liked this on Facebook.
Amanda Lannon liked this on Facebook.
Neil Young. And a splendid post.
The earliest reference I know to it being better to burn out than to rust out is from George Whitefield – but only because I’ve been reading about him recently, not because of any inherent knowledge of such matters.
Lois Baker liked this on Facebook.
@kouya title from George Whitefield I believe? The sentiment at least.
RT @kouya: It’s Better To Burn Out, Than It Is To Rust: … http://t.co/dDiriIzUo4
with reason Eddie!
Ruedi Giezendanner liked this on Facebook.
Tony Watkins liked this on Facebook.
I’ve never liked those pithy statements!
The article talks about ‘missionary administrators’ as if they have training for such traumas? My experience was that mostly they were people who never expected to be doing that job, but we’re doing it to fill a gap!
Here’s another version, from the Highlander movie, uttered by the Kurgan: “It’s better to burn out than to fade away!”
I reckon that comes from the same source as the quote I used.
Or as my psych interviewer said to me during my Wycliffe application, “don’t burn out or fade out – last out!”
That assumes you’ll be given the choice. In my experience, you can end up in the deep-end without ever choosing to do so.
That’s true enough; nothing has gone to plan since I first joined them, then left, then recently returned!
Eddie Arthur Most people have no idea what will burn them out until it’s too late
Absolutely – and even then they may not recognise it.
Eddie Arthur I reckon things can get spiritualised, and so not dealt with emotionally and practically quickly enough. Humanitarian agencies in my experience built in a better work/ rest schedule to help prevent the impact of so many pressures.
I would also add that ‘mission staff’ who have to raise their own support may feel pressurised to perform to a particular level for their support constituency.
There’s also (obviously) different kinds of burn out: war and violence is going to take a toll that you can’t do much about without getting out of the situation, whereas overwork (for whatever reason – self-imposed drivenness, inability to say no, enormity of the “unfinished task”) is something that can be managed and corrected for a bit more easily. *That* kind of burn-out is a lot more amenable to the “God’s work done God’s way” thing – but I agree that it’s not a great idea to moralize to people who are already hurting.
I bet too much e-mail would be a major source of burnout nowadays!
We teach trauma healing to those who have been through hurricanes, wars, earthquakes, ebola, etc. and seem to think that missionaries don’t need to know the same principles that we teach to others. We can do something about the trauma that we experience–we can talk to someone about what we are experiencing!
Debbie Fox liked this on Facebook.
JM Cheffy liked this on Facebook.
Here’s some good stuff on burnout from @kouya http://t.co/c3gFnUZWiQ #missions #burnout
Sue Arthur liked this on Facebook.
I think I’ve just learnt that Neil Young and Highlander quote George Whitefield.
@AlexGTHawke @kouya great blog. Thanks for sharing!
Caroline West liked this on Facebook.