Today, I’m going to do something that no charity CEO should do, I’m going to discuss a decision made by another organisation. In case you hadn’t heard, three days ago, World Vision USA (not any other part of World Vision) decided that they would employ staff who were married to a partner of the same sex. This decision was overturned two days later.
I don’t plan to look at the underlying questions about sexuality and employment in any depth, there are other blogs which do that sort of stuff far better than we could. All I want to do is make a few remarks from the point of view of cross-cultural mission.
- I think the initial decision by World Vision USA was wrong. This is partly because I hold to a traditional view of marriage but also because the decision was bound to be divisive.
- That being said, if they believed that the decision was the right one to take, they should have stuck with it. The fact that they could overturn such a major policy in just two days implies that they hadn’t really thought it through in depth.
- Christian Charities should make decisions based on Biblical values, not pragmatism and certainly not on the basis of what will bring in the most money. From the outside, it looks as though WV are bending one way and then the other in order to please their donors.
- Some of the reaction of Christians to this whole thing has not been pretty. When the initial decision was made, I saw some very nasty and ungracious things written about WV by conservative Christians. Then when it was reversed, some liberal and progressive Christians were just as vocal and just as unpleasant. I don’t care where you are on the theological spectrum, but if you can’t argue with grace and charity; stay away from social media.
- We’ve taken our eye off the ball. The purpose of World Vision is not to provide employment for Americans, be they gay or straight. They exist to serve the poor people of the world; who have been somewhat overlooked in this whole process.
- More importantly, yet again the Christian world is talking about sexuality and not about Christ. I know that issues of inclusion are important, I appreciate that charities have to make difficult decisions (tell me about it!), but there is a needy world out there that needs to hear the saving message of Christ crucified and a large part of the Christian world is consumed by an internal debate. This isn’t what we were sent to do.
I mentioned at the top that I hold to a traditional view of marriage. I know that some readers of Kouya Chronicle will disagree with me. Please can we just agree to disagree; I really don’t want the world mission focus of this post to be lost in the comments.Â

29 replies on “World Vision Turnaround”
Eddie, a very thoughtful post. I hope this doesn’t cross the line of your final exhortation.
I completely agree that the decision was going to be divisive, which leads on perfectly to your second point, but could you elaborate on why someone’s view on marriage would affect the recruitment policy? Doesn’t widening the recruitment net in fact make it easier to focus on the organisation’s objective of serving the poor? (Viz. Cranmer’s argument – which I’ll accept got a bit unnecessarily personal)
Hi Andy, thanks for your comments. I do hope the fact that I wrote it doesn’t actually contradict the key point I wanted to make. “That’s some catch that Catch 22”.
I’d love to read what you’ve written, but according to the error message I’m being prevented by Apaches!
Yes, the blog is poorly. I’m trying to get it fixed – I’ll put a note here when it is.
Geronimo! Circle the wagons, Dave!
Richard Young liked this on Facebook.
It does seem to be back again; give it a go.
thank you for posting this Eddie Arthur well thought out
They’ve certainly dropped the ball on communicating this; there’s nothing on their web site or press site about this, and heck, if you’re going to make a decision and then later declare *your own decision* to be a complete betrayal of the Trinitarian faith (as Richard Stearns has put it) then you do have an *awful* lot of explaining to do about how you got to the decision in the first place. I’d want to be saying something more than “well, we got it wrong”, and I’d want to be saying it as loudly as possible.
Simon Cozens liked this on Facebook.
Paul Bailie liked this on Facebook.
Incidentally, I heard very little about both changes from my Christian friends, and only heard about the latest reversal through the reaction of non-Christian friends on Facebook. It hasn’t been great for our witness.
See you Saturday when a certain charity CEO can forget such weighty issues and concentrate on making a speech in very happy circumstances 🙂
I love your point #5. Where are the voices of the poor in this topic? Does it matter what kind of organization they would find legitimate? Did WV take time to ask them?
Thanks for sharing. Hoping and praying that the adverse publicity doesn’t affect much needed fuds going to the poor
@kouya Well said. Strongly agree w/ #2: when you make a stand, at least stick with your decision otherwise you make it worse! Kyrie eleison.
Jon Barnes liked this on Facebook.
Andrew Crozier liked this on Facebook.
Amanda Lannon liked this on Facebook.
Wisely said, Sir. Our hearts go to the boy we supported for 4 years.
Good comment. Glad WV have reversed, but their understanding of what it means for an agency to relate to the teaching of churches needs fuller debate. I wonder also whether WV US have isolated themselves from other mission agencies in the same way that WV UK had withdrawn from GC.
I guess they realized that, practically speaking, it’s impossible not to “take a stand” on the issue after all! You’re right to highlight the reason why WV exists; I think if people pulled their support from WV they would most likely simply transfer their support to another organization, so the nasty rhetoric about gay people depriving kids of food was very unkind and blinkered! Overall, a very ugly episode which reveals what really lies just under the surface!
Nev McCormack liked this on Facebook.
Here is my take on the World Vision turn around. http://t.co/dwEMosgZNK Please can the church start talking about Jesus?
RT @kouya: Here is my take on the World Vision turn around. http://t.co/dwEMosgZNK Please can the church start talking about Jesus?
RT @kouya: Here is my take on the World Vision turn around. http://t.co/dwEMosgZNK Please can the church start talking about Jesus?
Good points most of them! If we’re going to disagree & we WILL – then at least do it with love, grace & forgiveness: http://t.co/2PZ8b79cnF
Hannah Victoria liked this on Facebook.
World Vision’s purpose is not to provide employment for Americans, B they gay or straight.They exist 2 serve the poor
http://t.co/ugQCRtkWyo