Please excuse a brief historical diversion…
In 1792, William Carey, a Baptist minister published the snappily titled An Enquiry into the Obligations of Christians to Use Means for the Conversion of the Heathens. By any standards, this is a remarkable book. It starts by setting out the biblical case for Christians being involved in world mission, then inspired by the voyages of Captain Cook and others, it goes on to survey the religious situation of the world, concluding that there is a great strategic need for mission. It is the final section of the book which is the most radical, however. Here, Carey suggests that Christians should establish societies (based on the model of the commercial societies which were doing such good business as world trade opened up) for spreading the Christian message around the world. This proposal provided the blueprint for the mission agencies which have been at the forefront of Protestant mission work for over 200 years. In fact, the basic structure of most agencies today is little removed from Carey’s suggestion.
Carey’s genius lay in understanding the biblical mandate for mission, analysing the world situation and coming up with a solution.
Today, the biblical mandate has not changed, but the world situation has. Carey wrote at a time when the Western world was broadly Christian and the rest of the world was not. This is simply no longer true.
Carey’s proposal for the founding of mission agencies was a response to a situation which no longer exists; which poses a rather uncomfortable question for today’s agencies. In short, are they still needed?
Often when I pose this question, people give a swift, indignant reply that of course agencies are still needed because there is still a need for Christian mission. However, this misses the point. Mission agencies and mission are not the same thing. Mission agencies are a relatively new innovation and were a response to a particular situation. A contextualised response, if you like – and now the context has changed.
The age of mission has not passed. God is doing remarkable things around the world. However, the age of Western Mission Agencies is almost certainly passing.
Maintaining structures, for the sake of the structures is always a mistake. We keep programmes, meetings and even churches going long past their sell-buy dates. We are loyal to our institutions and we seek to maintain them when their purpose no longer exists or when they are no longer viable. We do this because we mistake our own institutions for God’s bigger work.
So, where does this leave mission agencies? Put broadly, they will need to look very, very different in the future to the way they look now. I don’t know what the specific answers are, but if the leadership and boards of mission agencies are not asking these questions, they are missing out on their responsibilities. Undoubtedly, some agencies will need to close or merge and it is better than they think about this before it happens, rather than being forced into a situation in a panic.
Meanwhile, new structures and new types of agencies will develop all around the world as a new generation of Careys develop solutions to today’s situation. God’s mission will outlive our structures and will carry on till the earth is filled with the knowledge of the glory of God, as the waters cover the sea.

11 replies on “Are We Still Needed?”
RT @kouya: Are We Still Needed?: Some difficult reflections for mission agencies. http://t.co/nptZWePWeC
It’s a good question that, I think, goes beyond the life-cycle of organisations – as that life-cycle is normally measured in terms of financial ability to continue. Really we should be looking at impact, or even usefulness to the vision of the local church (where there is one) or the sending church. Of course, that’s almost impossible to measure and can be manipulated.
Phil Prior liked this on Facebook.
Are We Still Needed?: http://t.co/WvC4uVMODF via @kouya
One of those questions that mission agencies are to supposed to ask http://t.co/68BoyK3uPF
Mission doesn’t end (as you point out). Therefore, the need for a structure to carry out the mission doesn’t end (humans operating in large numbers need to have some form of organization). However, structures have changed over time, and will doubtless change again. The various existing mission structures are highly different in and of themselves: Cru, YWAM, Wycliffe, OM, IMB, GFA, NTM, AoG, GEMS, VV, IET, GMS, WEC, SIM, GMF, CB, P, ABWE, Frontiers, FMPB… all very large numbers (each about or over 1,000 workers) but all very different structures. Comparing IMB to YWAM or Wycliffe, and you’ll see the point. And these are vastly different from ancient structures (Catholic missionary orders, like the Celts, or even the tens of thousands of Jesuits, Franciscans, Dominicans, Augustinians…) or modern denominational structures. And of course there are many modern, small, structures enabling mission–churches sending their own workers, people going to start BAM networks, and the like. We cannot hold any single structure as being THE structure, ordained by God, and we have to hold them loosely. But that we NEED structure seems obvious.
I would agree that a case can be made for separate mission structures (though I’m not convinced that it is a black and white as you seem to suggest). However, it is a problem if we automatically assume that our current agency model is the right one (and I don’t think agencies differ as much as you say they do, either!).
Mission doesn’t end (as you point out). Therefore, the need for a structure to carry out the mission… http://t.co/yalAZLcgQ2
Susan van Wynen liked this on Facebook.
Phil – agree totally. Trustee bodies of mission agencies need to be asking far reaching questions, rather than just assessing if they have the finances to carry on.
Martin Lee liked this on Facebook.