Just a thought? Why do we make such a big thing about Epiphany and the visit of the Magi Mary, Joseph and their young child?
Let’s face, it we know very little about them. We don’t know where they came from, and we don’t really know who or what they were. The Bible certainly never applies the word ‘wise’ to them. There is no indication that they really understood who Jesus was, beyond being born to be King of the Jews – which in the Roman Empire could have meant more or less anything. We are not told that they read Scripture or that they had faith in anything beyond stars and dreams and we haven’t a clue how many of them there were!
They do play an important role in the overall narrative of Scripture. In the immediate context, they provide the background to the family’s flight to Egypt (and subsequent fulfilment of prophecy (Matthew 2:15) – something which was always important to Matthew). It also gives a reason for Herod’s slaughter of the innocents, which would have been still current in people’s memory when Matthew wrote his Gospel. On a broader scale, Matthew is introducing to his Jewish audience the notion that the Messiah will have an impact beyond the confines of Judaism. In this he is looking back to Isaiah 6 and forward to the early church.
I’m not convinced that this passage has any direct implications for our personal discipleship. The line ‘wise men still seek him’ is true and a good reminder, but I don’t think it is something you can draw from the passage. It doesn’t say they were wise, and beyond this one incident, there is no indication that they continued to seek him!
Viewed in the overall context of Scripture, the Magi story is twelve verses in one Gospel. Mark, Luke and John don’t mention it. I’m really not sure why we set aside a day for this one passage; when there are other events which are more prominent in the Bible which don’t get this sort of attention.

8 replies on “Why Make a Fuss About the Magi?”
I agree with you. DId you see this, by the way? http://www.economist.com/news/christmas-specials/21636508-what-those-magical-royal-wanderers-through-desert-really-signify-rule
I don’t know; I think we can say more about them than that. We know they are non-Jewish people, possibly from Persia, and we know the term “magos” refers to someone possessing magical arts. (See Daniel 2:2 LXX) In Matthew’s account the first people to visit *and worship* Jesus came from outside of Israel and outside the Jewish faith. That’s huge, especially if we agree that Matthew is writing to a predominantly Jewish audience. Also, we see their messianic expectation as a foil to Herod specifically and the people of Jerusalem in general who were “troubled” by the announcement of the king of the Jews. There’s also the (possible) prophetic nature of their gifts.
I think an application to personal discipleship falls out of that very easily: that we should always be on the look-out for the way that God speaks to and meets with people outside of the boundaries of what we think He can do, and that if we become complacent in our expectations of His activity, He will raise up people – even people outside the Church – to be prophetic witnesses against us. We need to be on the alert for God’s voice from whatever source it comes!
Andy Wilson Nelson liked this on Facebook.
Kaligbeu Georges Mario Zogbo Jr. liked this on Facebook.
Debbie Fox liked this on Facebook.
Elaine Pannell liked this on Facebook.
And God cares about people even if they are into activties that we would normally consider not very Christian! So we shouldn’t give up on people looking for answers in the wrong places. Also, these men were warned not to return to Herod, so they obeyed and went a different way. That shows they believed what they saw and it shows they were brave – because if discovered, they would probably have been killed for disobedience! So I think there is quite a bit of application there – though a whole day is possibly excessive!
Good point that it is probably seriously overrated. However, as others have already said, there is a lot more to learn from the passage, as with probably most Bible passages. One I read last week that really touched me was from Rowan Williams, which talked about circuitous and overly complicated ways the magi got to Jesus, but how they were just as welcome as the ‘simple’ shepherds. I am still welcome, even when I mess up by my efforts to understand everything.