“In Britain, it’s not just no-go zones, there are actual cities like Birmingham that are totally Muslim where non-Muslims just simply don’t go in,”
This absurd claim was made on Fox News yesterday by an someone called Steve Emerson from “the premier counterterrorism institute and data center”.
It’s hard to know how to respond to such idiocy. One response is to let the facts speak for themselves (The Muslim population of Birmingham is around 20%, not 100%).
Another, probably more effective, strategy is to laugh. There was a wonderful response on Twitter with the hashtag #FoxNewsFacts, which is well worth investigating. A couple of my favourite tweets were:
#foxnewsfacts The M6 toll road was built so non-muslims can avoid travelling through Birmingham. The toll paid goes towards building mosques
— DB (@dacy_essex) January 11, 2015
#FoxNewsFacts pic.twitter.com/x0HsHMmaOQ
— 🅡🅞🅑 🅜🅔🅢🅤🅡🅔 (@robmesure) January 11, 2015
Another response, one which was all too common, is to say something along the lines of ‘what do you expect from stupid Americans, they don’t understand the world at all’.
Firstly, this sort of silly stereotyping is just as ridiculous as the original statement from Fox News. There are plenty of Americans who do understand the wider world. You can’t make generalisations about the population of such a large country any more than you can make simplistic statements about the population of a city like Birmingham. Those who reacted to this story by classifying Americans in this way were falling into exactly the same trap as the Fox expert.
Perhaps the best response to this issue is to take some time to reflect on what it feels like to have your country or city misrepresented by a foreigner. The thing is that the media are full of this sort of silly generalisation. It’s true that things are rarely as blatant and silly as the story about Birmingham, but the way in which Africa, for example, is presented is hardly nuanced. How do Africans feel about the way in which Western media present their continent?
As outsiders, we all need to avoid making blankets statements about groups that we don’t know a great deal about; whether they be nations, world religions or those Christians in the church down the road.
Steve Emerson did apologise for his remarks, referring to Birmingham as a beautiful city – which confirmed to many that he really knew nothing about the place!

20 replies on “The Problem Of Birmingham”
I had no idea that there were so many Moslems in Alabama
Christiane Lauschitzky liked this on Facebook.
Evi Rodemann liked this on Facebook.
Phil Prior liked this on Facebook.
The idea of Birmingham being a no-go zone rather appeals to me 🙂
Phil Simpson liked this on Facebook.
Betty JoAnne Wilder liked this on Facebook.
I remember being in Birmingham. A whole crowd of us had to shelter in a supermarket awning from a tropical rainstorm, and an elderly Indian gentleman whiled away the time telling me how he had been thrown out of Uganda by Idi Amin. It was a lovely memory. (and absolutely true, as I was there and can testify to what I actually saw and heard – always helpful!)
It is time that Africans started speaking up. Fox needs to be put in their place! There are some places in the U.S. that a non Muslim would not want to go so I don’t understand why nothing was said about those cities!
I feel your pain. What a stupid statement. Reminds me of every time the BBC reports on America…
Exactly, Kevin!
Er, no…not really! Unless you actually have any example of this level of nonsense being peddled as ‘News’ by the BBC? I am willing to be corrected, but I won’t agree just for fun! 😉
Not quite sure what you’re saying there Jonathan but this item was on BBC Radio 4 this morning! Thankfully the presenters were enjoying taking the rip out of this bizarre ‘expert’. While his statements were utter nonsense, I do recall, last year after a disastrous attempt to catch a National Express bus from Leicester, ending up in Birmingham at the Bullring trying to orient myself and work out the way to the bus station to try a second attempt at catching the same bus. I had less than an hour to get there (more than enough time) but just could not figure my way around. I attempted more than half a dozen times to ask someone directions in the busy shopping area and none bar the last person could speak any English (and the last person didn’t know the way)! I made it to the bus with – I jest not – 30 seconds to spare. You can imagine how an anecdote like this could become ‘no one speaks any English in Birmingham’ and a new faux-statistic is born. I guess that’s why we need to take Abraham Lincoln’s quote seriously: “Never believe everything you see on the internet.” O.O
They’re all Brummies even the original inhabitants don’t speak English!
@Jonathan – http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-23541341. I love the headline: Tamerlan Tsarnaev had right-wing extremist literature. It could have read: The brothers had been reading militant Islamic websites before the bombings. Why did they choose the right wing slant over the the islamic extremeist slant. The BBC just cannot say anything good about the right, and their coverage over and over proves it.
@Kevin Are you saying it is untrue that he had white supremacist literature? Because what this guy on Fox News said was blatantly untrue, and correctable by a quick Google. If on the other hand you are saying there’s no difference between what you perceive as political bias and what the facts clearly demonstrate is a lie, then I strongly disagree with you, because there’s all the difference in the world between arguable bias and demonstrable untruth.
Kevin, it is hardly news that Tsarnaev “had been reading militant Islamic websites”, as mentioned in the BBC article. After all it is well known, and also mentioned in the article, that he was “passionate about Islam” (although also described as “just a Muslim of convenience”). But it is newsworthy that he also read white supremacist literature. Meanwhile, do you really think it shows bias to be negative about the views of apologists for Hitler?
But hang on Peter…your example is about the political leanings of our ‘august’ BBC, but that’s a long way away from bringing onto our screens (with the label of “expert”) someone who will state things as facts, when they are not facts, nor are they even remotely accurate statements.
Yep, the Beeb is often viewed as being left-inclined politically, and it receives a lot of stick for that. But, broadly speaking, it doesn’t allow those political leanings to significantly alter the news itself. I do sometimes cringe at HOW it presents the news, however! 😉
Jonathan, I think you misunderstand me. I am saying that this article doesn’t show any political leanings of the BBC except for opposition to white supremacists. We are not talking about the American equivalent of UKIP (the BBC wouldn’t be against them!) but hardcore racists who sometimes make the Nazis seem moderate.
To return to the original issue – is not this man’s idiocy a good warning not to quote something without checking it out yourself? Never trust another person’s quote without looking it up