I’m very challenged by this quote from Church in Hard Places.
One of the big claims of those supporting parachurch ministries – particularly those that operate within the context of the poor – is that they can effectively do what the church cannot. On one level that is true. Hundreds of thousands of people in Scotland are doubtless grateful for the food parcels they’ve received as the worldwide credit crunch bites. yet observing twenty-first-century Scottish schemes with their history of parachurch involvement, one has to wonder where is the long-term spiritual fruit after decades of parachurch labour? Where are the indigenous converts? Where are the healthy local churches? In my observation, they are nowhere. In fact there are fewer churches in these areas, not more.
That may seem harsh, but we have to face the hard facts. As Carl Trueman once said, “The parachurch exists purely and solely to serve the church in a subordinate and comparatively insignificant way.” Maybe this great parachurch experiment has not helped the local church after all. Whisper it softly, but maybe in some areas parachurches have weakened and not advanced the kingdom of God or built up Christ’s bride. So, for example, I have church members who are forced to miss three out of four Sunday services “working” for their parachurch organisation. Where are they worshipping in community? Nowhere. They have been taught that loyalty to their organisation is the height of worship.
As someone who has spent thirty years working for a “parachurch” organisation (we call it a mission agency, but the meaning is the same), I recognise some of the issues that Mez raises here. The temptation to downplay the role of the church is huge, but we must avoid it at all costs.
You may have noticed a few little changes and problems with Kouyanet in the past week or so. We have moved over to a new webhost and the process has not been smooth. When I get a little time, I’ll try and iron out any remaining glitches.Â

6 replies on “The Perils of Parachurch Ministry”
It’s easier to be snarky than it is to do something! I don’t think so many parachurch ministries would have grown up if the local churches had been doing their job properly. Just sayin’
I don’t think he is being snarky. He also makes the same point you do. However, I decided that typing out the whole chapter would take a lot of effort, as well as (probably) being a breach of copyright! However, in the world that I work in, I am far more likely to come across agency people dismissing the church than I am the opposite – hence my choice of quote.
He does put his finger on a challenge every parachurch ministry faces – how to be a special form of the church while serving the Church and not weakening other local instances of the Church. This is hard, and we have many instances of failure. While not saying that parachurch ministries should stop, I do think we should recognize the tension and grapple with it and always seek to do better.
Very interesting article, Eddie, thanks for posting. Wondering about reading the rest of the book now.
I recognise what he is saying. Having worked in different varieties of Para-Church organisation down the years, I am aware that it has often taken me away from church – often to the extreme annoyance of my church leaders (one of whom told me he hoped that I would not disappear in to the ‘bottomless pit’ of XX organisation when I joined the staff – several other member of my church at that time also worked for the same organsiation).
But there are ways in which my spiritual life is fed and watered by this work that it would not be in my local church, which is where I disagree a bit with the author. I disagrees in particular when he asks ‘Where are they worshipping in community? Nowhere. They have been taught that loyalty to their organisation is the height of worship.’ We pray and study the word together every morning as an organisation – we are a worshipping, praying, Word led community, I am regularly either leading / teaching or hearing others speaking on challenging issues in the world today with a strong scriptural analysis in way I just don’t hear in my local church.
All of this is, however, slanted around the issues current in my area of work, so it is still limited – we cannot replace the breadth of membership and teaching in a local congregation with the necessarily limited range and focus of para-church. So I do agree that where the emphasis of an organisation is so focused on its work that it takes staff too frequently away from the life of their local church or makes the organisation a priority over that local faith community, it is a dangerous thing. However it is not necessarily a spiritual wasteland working in the para-church either!
Melanie Carroll liked this on Facebook.