Recently, Wheaton College in the US sacked an assistant professor who, among other things, claimed that Christians and Muslims worship the same God (story here). Twitter immediately went into meltdown, with people arguing vociferously on both sides of the argument. A lot of heat and a little bit of light was generated in the process.
Normally, I leave these internet storms to run their course, no one needs yet another opinion on the question of the day. However, I thought I’d pick this one up because it fits in with the brief look we’ve been taking at John’s Gospel.
So, do Christians and Muslims worship the same God? In my view, the best way to answer this is actually to take a look at the God that Christians worship and then say whether that is the God that Muslims worship. I’m qualified to do the former, less so to do the latter.
Back to John’s Gospel
In the beginning the Word already existed.
    The Word was with God,
    and the Word was God.
He existed in the beginning with God.
In his introduction, John calls Jesus of Nazareth “the Word” and says that he has existed before time, he was with God and that (crucially) he is God. A few verses later he adds this
God created everything through him,
    and nothing was created except through him.
So John is claiming that Jesus of Nazareth, a young man born in Bethlehem and executed by the Romans was the eternal creator God. Paul underlines this in his introduction to Colossians (Col 1:15,16).
Christ is the visible image of the invisible God.
    He existed before anything was created and is supreme over all creation,
for through him God created everything
    in the heavenly realms and on earth.
He made the things we can see
    and the things we can’t see—
such as thrones, kingdoms, rulers, and authorities in the unseen world.
    Everything was created through him and for him.
For the writers of the New Testament, Jesus Christ was God. It gets a bit more complicated, because they also realised that the Holy Spirit was God, too. There is one God in three persons; Father, Son and Spirit. This isn’t the place to try and explain the Trinity (were I so bold), but this is the God that the Bible reveals to us.
One of the great paradoxes of the faith is that almighty God, the creator of the universes took on human form (while remaining fully God), was born as a baby and laid in a manager, because there was no where else to put him. In fact he was so humble, that he even allowed himself to be arrested, tried and executed by people that he had created. This is the God of the Bible, the God of the Christian faith.
I can’t speak for other religions, but if your God was not born into a human family and laid in a feeding trough, then you don’t worship the God that Christians worship. Whatever the similarities between different religions, Jesus changes everything.
Though he was God,
    he did not think of equality with God
    as something to cling to.
Instead, he gave up his divine privileges;
    he took the humble position of a slave
    and was born as a human being.
When he appeared in human form,
he humbled himself in obedience to God
    and died a criminal’s death on a cross.
Therefore, God elevated him to the place of highest honour
    and gave him the name above all other names,
that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow,
    in heaven and on earth and under the earth,
and every tongue declare that Jesus Christ is Lord,
    to the glory of God the Father.
By the way, if you would like to read more about the Trinity, I can’t recommend Delighting in the Trinity by Tim Chester and The Good God: Enjoying Father, Son and Spirit by Mike Reeves highly enough. Both are excellent, accessible introductions to the Trinity and I would argue that every Chrisitan should read at least one of them.

29 replies on “The Same God?”
RT @kouya: if your God was not born and laid in a feeding trough, then you don’t worship the God as Christians… https://t.co/rGBocxxQ5Y
Jill Roth liked this on Facebook.
Jon Barnes liked this on Facebook.
Gareth Hides liked this on Facebook.
Paul Bailie liked this on Facebook.
Ian Rees liked this on Facebook.
Eddie, at the risk of adding to the heat and obscuring the light, allow me to disagree politely with this. Hawkins was not saying that we believe the same things about God, which would obviously be wrong (and in which case your criticisms would be valid). She was following a very well-established (ie hundreds of years old) line of thought which says that there is enough commonality in the Jewish, Christian and Muslim ideas of God, in terms of our theological statements and our origins, for that to be a helpful way of putting it. That seems obvious to me. & BTW, saying that you have to believe in the Incarnation if you’re to worship the same God means you rule out Jews, too, which is theologically a bit weird.
I don’t think you are adding heat, Mark. Yours is a helpful comment and I agree with it in as much as the similarities do provide scope for helpful dialogue. However, while noting your caveat about the Jews, I do see the Trinity (implying the incarnation) as the identifying mark of the Christian God.
As always with my blog posts, I’ve not unpacked all of the implications.
Thanks again for a good comment which adds to the discussion.
I don’t think Hawkins has been sacked yet, but is suspended until further review. This CNN article helps put the college’s actions in perspective, especially in its comparison to what was said at Liberty U not long before the events at Wheaton. http://edition.cnn.com/2015/12/20/opinions/wheeler-wheaton-college-suspends-professor/index.html
Thanks Rosalee; this is helpful.
Thecla Perkins liked this on Facebook.
Elaine Pannell liked this on Facebook.
Tony Watkins liked this on Facebook.
Kaligbeu Georges Mario Zogbo Jr. liked this on Facebook.
I’m with Mark on this. The fact we believe different things about God does not mean we believe in different Gods. The God of Abraham is the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. The difference surely is to do with how fully he has revealed himself – or how we believe him to have revealed himself. For us as Christians the fullest revelation we have of him is in Christ and we delight therefore in the centrality of the incarnation. But others who do not believe in that fullest revelation do not necessarily believe in a different God – though inevitably they will believe different things about him. isn’t that the point of Acts 17:23?
I get what you are saying. However, if we attribute things to God which are not true and refuse to accept things about him which are true (which we all do to some extent) then there comes a point at which our conception of God is so far removed from reality as to be a different God altogether. There are still missional links that can be forged in many different situations, including pagan Athens.
Being created in the image of God, there is a shadow of the Triune one in all human searches for Him; but the shadow and the reality are not always the same.
I always enjoy what you write, Eddie. However I think it ‘fairer’ to ask if Jews and Muslims worship the same God ie to compare between the God of the OT to the Quran in terms of revelation. If the answer if yes, then we have, I believe, already established that Christians worship the same God as the God of the Jews I’m not sure the God of the OT would get past your incarnation test ……… which obviously is based on NT revelation.
Not the same, no – but equally not unrelated (otherwise it’d be a shadow of something else!).
Ric Nelson liked this on Facebook.
I don’t think there’s a theologically justifiable way to thread this needle which includes “the God of the Jews” but excludes “the God of the Muslims” – which basically is what Wheaton are trying to do. And that speaks more about their political agenda than their theological integrity.
I agree that you have asked the right question but not so sure about your implied answer. Does a Jew (today) worship the same God as a Christian? How can they when Christians believe that Jesus IS God? As Eddie says, the trinity does set Christianity distinctly apart from all religions, even monotheistic ones.
So, here’s a fun one: did Jesus worship the God of the Jews?
Exactly. Can God worship himself? The continuity/discontinuity between Judaism & Christianity is one of the things that keeps theologians in business. The fact the Christians were eventually kicked out of the synagogue suggests that the Jews came to the conclusion that they worshipped a different God.
I think I want to go with C S Lewis on offerings to Tash and Aslan
John Leaver liked this on Facebook.
Unpacking the questioner’s assumptions may help clarify the question. I suspect that when people ask “Are they the same God?” they are also asking “Can either lead to salvation?” Answering the first question does not necessarily answer the second.
It’s also useful to think from a broader missiological perspective: what do we say to e.g. African tribes who worship a High God? Sorry, your High God is not the High God, our High God is… It actually becomes nonsensical. (After all, how many Gods do we believe there are?) The more important question, as Martin Goldsmith says, is not “is it the same God?” but “what sort of correctives need to be applied to the understanding of God?”
RT @kouya: if your God was not born and laid in a feeding trough, then you don’t worship the God as Christians… https://t.co/rGBocxxQ5Y
There is only one God. People of many religions worship Him, but without knowing what He is really like. When talking with Muslims, we cannot use ‘our god’ versus ‘your god’ language. That communicates nothing except confusion, and is theologically incorrect. However, we can share what we know, that God is loving and that he chose to make his home among us.